# Review Log

## Task: T-001

### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T11:03:20Z

- Findings: no required fixes; implementation and package comments match the plan.
- Tests first: targeted tests initially failed on missing symbols, then passed after implementation.
- Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, and `git diff --check` PASS.
- Environment retry: initial validation hit a read-only Go build cache; rerun with approved cache access passed. No code retries or weakened assertions.
- E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED; this task contains only pure logic and parsing.
- Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`.

## Task: T-002

### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T11:17:06Z

- Findings: no required fixes; reviewed the complete diff against the sampler, MQTT, HTTP, page, and configuration plan. Comments document interval semantics and shutdown ownership; README remains assigned to T-003.
- Tests first: sampler, HTTP, and configuration tests failed on missing symbols before implementation, then passed unchanged.
- Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, `go test -race ./...`, and staged/unstaged diff checks PASS.
- E2E: no repository E2E command configured. Temporary `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-smoke.mjs` PASS using an isolated Mosquitto container and real Chrome. Verified initial broker outage/retry, autonomous samples, 2.99/3.00 W boundary, malformed messages, gaps, reconnect/resubscribe, API, and SIGTERM exit 0.
- Browser: 360px viewport, all four messages/colors, white background, large status, black readings, 47.70W/-- formatting, 60s timer, failed fetch/recovery, and no horizontal overflow PASS. Screenshot: `/tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-mobile.png`.
- Implementation smoke retry: Docker reassigned a dynamically published broker port after restart; fixed the temporary harness to reserve an explicit port. All assertions retained; rerun passed. No product-code or review validation retries.
- Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`.

## Task: T-003

### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T11:22:18Z

- Findings: no required fixes; multi-stage static image, Compose variables, build context exclusions, and README match the plan. No application behavior changed in this task.
- Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, `docker compose config --quiet`, Docker build, and diff checks PASS.
- Packaging smoke: `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-docker-smoke.mjs` PASS. Verified non-root scratch image (6,754,466 bytes), custom HTTP port/broker/topic/sample interval, actual Docker-network MQTT sampling, embedded page/API, missing samples, graceful stop with exit 0, rejection of zero duration, and all Compose environment overrides. Temporary containers/network removed.
- Documentation: original README content from `## AI Workflow` onward is byte-for-byte unchanged. Setup, rules, all six env vars, TelePeriod, API, manual validation, and limitations documented.
- E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED as a repository command; temporary packaging smoke PASS. T-002 browser/MQTT smoke also passed.
- Environment retry during implementation: Docker build metadata was read-only under the sandbox; approved rerun built successfully. No review validation retries or weakened assertions.
- Workflow limitation: `aide pr --dry-run` rejected the current `main` branch. AGENTS.md requires working in the current branch, so no branch change or PR creation was performed.
- Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`.

## Task: T-004

### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T13:17:23Z

- Mechanical retry 1 (`go test -race ./...`): the test recorder's body read before advancing synthetic time was not synchronized with the subsequent keep-alive write. Synchronize the recorder fixture's writes and body reads; retain all assertions and expected behavior. No product race was reported.
- Retry 1 result: fmt/vet/test/race PASS after synchronizing the test recorder; no assertions weakened or removed.

### Final verification — 2026-10-12T13:18:18Z

- Findings: no required fixes or semantic concerns. Reviewed the staged and unstaged diff against T-004; status rules, JSON contract, and sampling remain unchanged. Hub broadcasts coalesce without blocking; callbacks execute after storage outside the sampler lock; SSE subscribers and blocked writes clean up on cancellation.
- Tests first: Go tests failed on missing Hub/callback/handler symbols before implementation; temporary page behavior checks failed on missing EventSource before page changes. Shutdown completion was fixed during implementation without changing its assertion.
- Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, `go test -race ./...`, and staged/unstaged diff checks PASS.
- E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED as a repository command. Temporary `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t004-smoke.mjs` PASS with isolated Mosquitto and real Chrome: initial events, multiple subscribers, invalid payload suppression, disconnect/reconnect, streams surviving the actual 10-second timeout, actual 25-second keep-alives, browser refresh on MQTT, sampled readings at 360px, and prompt clean SIGTERM shutdown with active streams.
- Page behavior: temporary `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t004-page-test.mjs` PASS for burst coalescing, 60-second polling, no EventSource support, and failed-fetch recovery. Screenshot inspected: `/tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t004-mobile.png`.
- Documentation: README covers SSE format, refresh behavior, sampling, keep-alives, proxy buffering, and manual checks; AI Workflow section is byte-for-byte unchanged.
- Environment retries: Go formatting/testing needed writable build-cache access; staging needed writable Git-index access. Approved reruns passed.
- Workflow limitation: `aide pr --dry-run` refuses the current `main` branch. Kept the current branch as instructed; no PR created.
- Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`.