# Review Log ## Task: T-001 ### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T11:03:20Z - Findings: no required fixes; implementation and package comments match the plan. - Tests first: targeted tests initially failed on missing symbols, then passed after implementation. - Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, and `git diff --check` PASS. - Environment retry: initial validation hit a read-only Go build cache; rerun with approved cache access passed. No code retries or weakened assertions. - E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED; this task contains only pure logic and parsing. - Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`. ## Task: T-002 ### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T11:17:06Z - Findings: no required fixes; reviewed the complete diff against the sampler, MQTT, HTTP, page, and configuration plan. Comments document interval semantics and shutdown ownership; README remains assigned to T-003. - Tests first: sampler, HTTP, and configuration tests failed on missing symbols before implementation, then passed unchanged. - Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, `go test -race ./...`, and staged/unstaged diff checks PASS. - E2E: no repository E2E command configured. Temporary `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-smoke.mjs` PASS using an isolated Mosquitto container and real Chrome. Verified initial broker outage/retry, autonomous samples, 2.99/3.00 W boundary, malformed messages, gaps, reconnect/resubscribe, API, and SIGTERM exit 0. - Browser: 360px viewport, all four messages/colors, white background, large status, black readings, 47.70W/-- formatting, 60s timer, failed fetch/recovery, and no horizontal overflow PASS. Screenshot: `/tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-mobile.png`. - Implementation smoke retry: Docker reassigned a dynamically published broker port after restart; fixed the temporary harness to reserve an explicit port. All assertions retained; rerun passed. No product-code or review validation retries. - Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`. ## Task: T-003 ### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T11:22:18Z - Findings: no required fixes; multi-stage static image, Compose variables, build context exclusions, and README match the plan. No application behavior changed in this task. - Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, `docker compose config --quiet`, Docker build, and diff checks PASS. - Packaging smoke: `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-docker-smoke.mjs` PASS. Verified non-root scratch image (6,754,466 bytes), custom HTTP port/broker/topic/sample interval, actual Docker-network MQTT sampling, embedded page/API, missing samples, graceful stop with exit 0, rejection of zero duration, and all Compose environment overrides. Temporary containers/network removed. - Documentation: original README content from `## AI Workflow` onward is byte-for-byte unchanged. Setup, rules, all six env vars, TelePeriod, API, manual validation, and limitations documented. - E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED as a repository command; temporary packaging smoke PASS. T-002 browser/MQTT smoke also passed. - Environment retry during implementation: Docker build metadata was read-only under the sandbox; approved rerun built successfully. No review validation retries or weakened assertions. - Workflow limitation: `aide pr --dry-run` rejected the current `main` branch. AGENTS.md requires working in the current branch, so no branch change or PR creation was performed. - Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`. ## Task: T-004 ### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T13:17:23Z - Mechanical retry 1 (`go test -race ./...`): the test recorder's body read before advancing synthetic time was not synchronized with the subsequent keep-alive write. Synchronize the recorder fixture's writes and body reads; retain all assertions and expected behavior. No product race was reported. - Retry 1 result: fmt/vet/test/race PASS after synchronizing the test recorder; no assertions weakened or removed. ### Final verification — 2026-10-12T13:18:18Z - Findings: no required fixes or semantic concerns. Reviewed the staged and unstaged diff against T-004; status rules, JSON contract, and sampling remain unchanged. Hub broadcasts coalesce without blocking; callbacks execute after storage outside the sampler lock; SSE subscribers and blocked writes clean up on cancellation. - Tests first: Go tests failed on missing Hub/callback/handler symbols before implementation; temporary page behavior checks failed on missing EventSource before page changes. Shutdown completion was fixed during implementation without changing its assertion. - Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, `go test -race ./...`, and staged/unstaged diff checks PASS. - E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED as a repository command. Temporary `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t004-smoke.mjs` PASS with isolated Mosquitto and real Chrome: initial events, multiple subscribers, invalid payload suppression, disconnect/reconnect, streams surviving the actual 10-second timeout, actual 25-second keep-alives, browser refresh on MQTT, sampled readings at 360px, and prompt clean SIGTERM shutdown with active streams. - Page behavior: temporary `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t004-page-test.mjs` PASS for burst coalescing, 60-second polling, no EventSource support, and failed-fetch recovery. Screenshot inspected: `/tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t004-mobile.png`. - Documentation: README covers SSE format, refresh behavior, sampling, keep-alives, proxy buffering, and manual checks; AI Workflow section is byte-for-byte unchanged. - Environment retries: Go formatting/testing needed writable build-cache access; staging needed writable Git-index access. Approved reruns passed. - Workflow limitation: `aide pr --dry-run` refuses the current `main` branch. Kept the current branch as instructed; no PR created. - Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`. ## Task: T-005 ### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-12T13:24:25Z - Findings: no required fixes or semantic concerns. The diff matches T-005: the done state uses `#1a7f37`, the page test requires that rule, and the README status table says Green. Status logic, messages, other colors, and README AI Workflow content are unchanged. - Tests first: `go test ./internal/web` failed because the green `.done` rule was missing, then passed after the CSS change with the assertion retained. - Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, and `git diff --check` PASS. - E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED as documented in README; optional browser smoke not run for this CSS-only change. - Environment retry during implementation: sandbox blocked the Go build-cache write; approved rerun reached the expected failing test. No review retries or weakened assertions. - Workflow limitation: `aide pr --dry-run` refuses the current `main` branch. Kept the current branch as instructed; no PR created. - Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`. ## Task: T-006 ### Review Round 1 — 2026-10-13T09:08:01Z - Findings: no required fixes or semantic concerns. The complete staged/unstaged diff matches the manifest, exact asset routes, head tags, icon design, and documentation plan. Status logic, API JSON, SSE, page title/layout/script, and the README AI Workflow section are unchanged. - Tests first: `go test ./internal/web` failed on all six missing routes, missing page tags, and missing manifest before implementation; all assertions passed after implementation and were retained. - Validation: `go fmt ./...`, `go vet ./...`, `go test ./...`, `go test -race ./internal/web`, and staged/unstaged diff checks PASS. - Assets: PNGs rendered from the committed SVG using headless Chrome; inspected all PNGs plus a circular mask preview. Pixel checks confirm the maskable icon is fully opaque and all foreground artwork is inside the central safe circle. All declared PNG dimensions decode correctly. - Packaging/browser smoke: Docker build and temporary `node /tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t006-smoke.mjs` PASS. The scratch image serves byte-identical embedded assets; curl HEAD, GET, content types, cache headers, and POST 405 pass for all six routes. Chrome at 360px reports no DevTools manifest errors and decodes every icon at its declared size. Page, API, initial SSE event, and clean shutdown pass. Screenshot: `/tmp/mqtt-washingmachine-t006-mobile.png`. - E2E: NOT_CONFIGURED as a repository command. Temporary Docker/Chrome smoke passed; physical Android home-screen installation was not exercised. - Environment retries: Docker build metadata and the Git index were read-only in the sandbox; approved reruns passed. No review validation retries or weakened assertions. - Workflow limitation: `aide pr --dry-run` refuses the current `main` branch. Kept the current branch as instructed; no PR created. - Verdict: PASS, approved for the per-task commit under `all_task`.