CamMonitor/.ai/REVIEW.md

REVIEW

Append-only reviewer log. Each reviewed task gets one section.

---

T-001 — Project scaffold

Verdict: PASS_WITH_NOTES

Findings

#	Severity	File	Description	Required fix?
1	nit	.env.example	Missing DB_PATH and LISTEN_ADDR entries. The plan requires .env.example to document all env vars; the README does cover them but the example file operators copy is incomplete.	no
2	nit	docker-compose.yml	LISTEN_ADDR env var is not forwarded into the container; the port mapping hardcodes 8080 as the inner port. If an operator sets LISTEN_ADDR to something other than :8080 only locally editing the compose file would fix the mismatch.	no
3	nit	internal/db/db.go	SQLite connection pool is not limited to a single open connection. Concurrent writes (introduced in T-002) risk SQLITE_BUSY / "database is locked" errors. Consider adding database.SetMaxOpenConns(1) before the health check in a future task.	no
4	nit	README.md	Contains extensive AI workflow boilerplate (workflow profiles, session commands, file map, etc.) that is unrelated to the application's end-user docs. The plan scope for README was quick-start, env var reference, and footage directory format — all of which are present.	no

Required fixes

None — all findings are nits. No blocking issues.

Verification

Steps performed:

1. Read all T-001 files: cmd/server/main.go, internal/config/config.go, internal/db/db.go, internal/web/router.go, internal/web/router_test.go, Dockerfile, docker-compose.yml, .env.example, go.mod, README.md, .dockerignore.
2. Cross-checked implementation against .ai/PLAN.md Phase 1 scope.
3. Ran go fmt ./... — clean (no output).
4. Ran go vet ./... — clean.
5. Ran go test ./... — internal/web PASS, other packages report no test files (correct for T-001 scope).
6. Ran go test -race ./... — PASS, no data races.
7. docker compose build and curl -i http://127.0.0.1:18080/health verified by implementer evidence; both passed.

Findings:

• All acceptance criteria met: docker compose build succeeds (per evidence), GET /health returns 200 and {"status":"ok"} (covered by test + E2E evidence), go vet ./... passes.
• Health handler correctly sets Content-Type: application/json before writing the body.
• Router test covers both status code and JSON body parsing — adequate for T-001 scope.
• Multi-stage Dockerfile matches plan exactly (golang:1.22-bookworm builder → debian:bookworm-slim + ffmpeg runtime).
• CGO_ENABLED=0 build flag is correct; aligns with the no-CGO constraint.
• modernc.org/sqlite (pure-Go) is the only SQLite driver imported — constraint satisfied.

Risks:

• SQLite connection pool (finding #3) will matter in T-002; surfaced early so the implementer can address it then.
• .env.example gaps (finding #1) are low-risk for a scaffold task but should be cleaned up before shipping.

---